Kazakhstan is the largest country in Central Asia and home to the
region’s second-largest population, with around 19 million citizens. The
population is around 70 percent Sunni Muslim, 26 percent Christian
(including Orthodox, Protestants, Catholics, and Jehovah’s Witnesses),
3 percent other (including Jews, Buddhists, Baha’is, and Hare Krishnas),
and less than 1 percent Shi’a Muslims, mostly ethnic Azeris. A total
of 3,826 officially registered religious associations represent 18 religious groups in Kazakhstan and 3,597 registered places of worship.
Approximately two-thirds of the population are ethnic Kazakhs—a
Turkic people group—while the rest are ethnic Slavs and other Turkic
peoples, including Uzbeks and Uyghurs. Kazakhstan is the only Central
Asian country with a large ethnic Russian population, mostly in the north.
The government is avowedly secular and seeks to control religion, which it views as a potentially destabilizing force. It maintains
influence over, and preference for, what it considers the “traditional”
Hanafi school of Sunni Islamic jurisprudence; it is generally wary of
other Islamic practices emanating from the wider Muslim world. It
classifies as traditional and nonthreatening other religions with a
long-established presence and good relations with the government—
like Orthodox Christianity, Roman Catholicism, and Judaism—while
viewing with suspicion newer arrivals to the region, such as evangelical Christianity and Scientology. The government is particularly
concerned about the spread of religious extremism, which it defines
broadly and uses to target political opponents, as well as the potential for perceived social disruption from proselytism and missionary
activity. Although concerns about extremist violence are legitimate,
the government’s vague conception of religious extremism is applicable to any nonviolent activity it sees as potentially disruptive—even
private religious practice and instruction.
Corruption, particularly at the local level, remained one of the
more persistent problems impeding religious freedom; for example,
some religious groups reported attempts at blackmail or bribery by
local officials. The solicitation of bribes by local police was reportedly a contributing factor behind deadly clashes in February when
angry Kazakh mobs targeted the ethnic Dungan community, a Muslim
Chinese minority. Official religious policy may have contributed to
these clashes by linking Kazakh national identity with Hanafi Islam and
equating “foreign” Islam with extremism; in doing so, the government
has arguably helped to foster an environment hostile to religious and
ethnic minorities like the Dungan.
Ethnic Kazakh Refugees from Xinjiang
The Chinese Communist Party has imprisoned large numbers of
ethnic Kazakhs alongside Uyghur Muslims in China’s massive concentration camps in the Xinjiang region. Partly in response to this
crisis, President Tokayev signed amendments to Kazakhstan’s migration law in May, changing the term used to describe ethnic Kazakh
migrants from oralman (returnee) to kandas (native/blood related)
as part of a broader effort to ease legal residency and citizenship
for Kazakh refugees from Xinjiang. In October, four ethnic Kazakhs
who had fled Xinjiang and entered Kazakhstan illegally were granted
temporary refugee status, marking this shift in policy. Even so, relations between Beijing and Nur-Sultan remained close; in August,
the Chinese ambassador praised military cooperation between the
two countries and vowed to strengthen mutual efforts to combat
extremism. This statement fueled concerns about China’s influence
in Kazakhstani security policy and the potential spread of expansive counterextremism tactics modeled on those China has used
in Xinjiang.
Key U.S. Policy
Ongoing Challenges
Although the number of administrative charges has dropped, in 2020
religious minorities still reported facing intimidation tactics from
government authorities, including hostile interrogations, threats
of punishment, surveillance, and periodic detention. The government seized the property of several Protestant churches, groups
advocating for religious freedom and broader human rights faced
official smear campaigns and fines, and peaceful religious minorities
continued to face prosecution as extremists. For example, beginning in May, the Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights
and Rule of Law (KMBPCh) and other NGOs faced a concerted government smear campaign, in which they were accused of trying to
destabilize the country at the behest of foreign interests. Yevgeny
Zhovtis, the director of KMBPCh, is a frequent and vocal critic of
official religious policy; he argued in October that all restrictions on
the individual right to freedom of religion and belief clearly violate
the Constitution of Kazakhstan. Furthermore, Scientologists reported
that members in Nur-Sultan were required to attend “preventative
consultations,” where they were threatened and ordered to sign a
statement denouncing and disavowing Scientology.
The United States and Kazakhstan enjoyed a close partnership in
2020, including two sessions of the U.S.-Kazakhstan Working Group
on Religious Freedom. In February, then Secretary of State Michael
R. Pompeo traveled to Kazakhstan and met with President Tokayev
to discuss improving relations between the two countries. The then
secretary also reiterated his admiration for Kazakhstan’s leadership in reintegrating citizens from Syria and Iraq, and he expressed
concern over the situation in neighboring Xinjiang. The U.S. government delivered $6.2 million of assistance, including essential
laboratory equipment and supplies, to support Kazakhstani efforts
to fight COVID-19. Meanwhile, USAID continued to support programs in Kazakhstan to promote civil society, good governance, and
human rights, including efforts to foster relationships between the
Kazakhstani government and civil society organizations and support
partnerships for reform. In November, then Assistant Secretary of
State for Educational and Cultural Affairs Marie Royce met with Kazakh
and Uyghur refugees from Xinjiang during her visit to Kazakhstan,
where she also discussed bilateral engagement on education and
culture with government officials.
U S C I R F – R E C O M M E N D E D F O R S P E C I A L W AT C H L I S T
77
K AZAKHSTAN
Background
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents