A/HRC/25/CRP.1
executed. In the case of Christians, the SSD tried to ascertain how long a person had
been a Christian. They looked at the circumstances, e.g. whether the person tried to
bring Bibles into the DPRK. In such cases, the persons were typically sent to prison
camps without a trial.517
• One former security official indicated that he received orders from his superiors to
classify “defectors” into three groups. The first group were those who crossed the
border only for food with the intention of coming back to the DPRK – they were to
be sent to labour camps for three to six months. The second group were those who
left the DPRK with the intention of reaching the ROK – they were to be sent to an
ordinary prison camp (kyohwaso). The third group were those who leave the DPRK
with the intention of going to the ROK using channels provided by Christian groups
or the ROK intelligence network – they were to be sent to a political prison camp
(kwanliso). Public executions of “defectors” were carried out where politically
expedient.518
• Another former SSD agent indicated that people forcibly repatriated from China
were treated entirely differently from those who returned to the DPRK voluntarily.
They were to be interrogated as to whether they had been in contact with churches
or with ROK nationals, and, if so, they were to be sent to the SSD provincial
headquarters and from there to a kwanliso. The rest were to be sent to MPS facilities
and from there to an ordinary prison (kyohwaso).519
(i)
Torture and inhuman treatment during interrogation
411. The Commission finds that during the interrogation carried out by the SSD and
MPS, severe beatings and other forms of torture are systematically used, until the
interrogators are convinced that the victim has stated the truth and confessed to the totality
of his or her wrongdoing. With rare exceptions, every single one of more than 100 persons
repatriated from China who were interviewed by the Commission were beaten or subjected
to worse forms of torture during interrogations. Inhumane detention conditions that
characterize the interrogation detention centres of the SSD and MPS exert additional
pressure on detainees to confess quickly to secure their survival.520
412. During the interrogation phase, suspects receive a quantity of rations that is designed
to cause hunger and starvation. In some interrogation detention centres, inmates are also
subjected to forced labour in farming and construction. This violates international standards
which prohibit imposing forced labour on persons not duly convicted.521 Inmates who are
not being interrogated or who are not working have to sit or kneel the entire day in a fixed
posture in often severely overcrowded cells. They are not allowed to speak, move, or look
around without permission. Failure to obey these rules will be punished by beatings, food
ration cuts or forced physical exercise. Punishment is often imposed collectively on all
cellmates.
• Mr Kim Song-ju said at the London Public Hearing: “As soon as I set my foot back
in North Korea, the treatment of me was [as though I was] below human... In the
course of interrogating me, they hit me, because they asked me whether I was in
contact with South Koreans, or if I had gotten involved with any religious acts, but
517
518
519
520
521
TJH015.
TJH004.
TJH041.
See also section IV.E for more details and illustrative examples on torture, deliberate starvation and
inhumane conditions of detention imposed on persons held at interrogation detention centres.
See further section IV.E on international standards.
115